Best of 2016: Baird seizes financial control of NSW councils

Commitments… he’s made a few. pic: Facebook


The Baird Government has moved to seize direct financial control of councils across New South Wales under sweeping new laws that hand ultimate power over local government spending to specially appointed “controllers”, with oversight duties handed to the State Auditor General.

Revealed in the immediate wake of this week’s NSW Budget, the new legislation — the Local Government Amendment (Governance and Planning) 2016 — proposes to impose the tightest controls yet on how elected representatives and council staff spend money and includes the right to shut out general managers from financial probes of expenditure and governance.

The new laws could also hand State Government appointed administrators the power to make ‘opt-in’ decisions on behalf of electors and elected representatives on controversial issues like the use of postal voting at merged councils thanks to the delay of polls until September 2017.

Rushed into the Legislative Assembly this week, the new controls won’t be debated until the August sitting of State Parliament but have already sent shockwaves across a sector still reeling from the sacking of 37 councils in May.

[quote]One of the legislative changes sure to raise hackles is a bid to “remove procedural requirements relating to the community strategic plan, community engagement strategy, resource ng strategy, delivery program and operational plan.”[/quote]

Local Government Minister Paul Toole is making no apologies and said the new laws make “important changes to ensure councils are always putting the interests of local communities first.”

That includes far greater powers for direct ministerial intervention.

“It will enable the Government to appoint a financial controller to councils that have a consistent record of poor financial performance and get those councils back on track,” Mr Toole said.

The hotly contested financial state and sustainability of local governments across NSW was the main trigger for forcing council amalgamations across the state, premised on the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal’s heavily disputed ‘Fit of the Future’ report card.

But many councils – amalgamated or otherwise – have attacked the financial assessments made of them in the run-up to mergers as flawed, particularly smaller and more buoyant local governments amalgamated with fiscally challenged neighbours.


Councils hit back

Local Government NSW (LGNSW), the peak representative body for councils in the state, is suspicious of the bid to parachute-in financial controllers as the Minister sees fit, cautioning some of the state government’s financial assessment methods simply lack credibility.

“Many of these moves seem designed to establish new avenues for central oversight and control, rather than recognising that local government is an autonomous, elected sphere of government,” said LGNSW President Keith Rhoades.

“There needs to be agreed parameters around the Government appointing a financial controller, and objective measures of “poorly performing” or “high financial sustainability risk” need to be established. Lack of specificity could allow the Government to apply the same discredited methods used to declare many NSW councils “not fit for the future,” Cllr Rhoades said.

City of Sydney Councillor Ed Mandla, a Liberal, also had reservations as the the efficacy of the new laws.

“Surely the best oversight for council books is the ballot box,” Cllr Mandla told Government News.

[quote]”The real problem for for Councillors is if they have a problem with the GM (general manager) they have to tell the mayor and if they have a problem with the mayor they have to tell the GM — what if they are in cahoots?”[/quote]


Questionable Timing

The latest laws are the second major tranche of legislation to hit this week, with another bill dealing with the donations and the pecuniary interests of councillors – the Local Government and Elections Legislation Amendment Integrity Bill – introduced on Budget night.

The timing of the new legislation prompted Labor Opposition Leader Luke Foley to accuse Mr Toole and Premier Baird of trying to sneak through the new laws and of reneging on a promise to introduce limits on donations, especially from property developers.

“Mr Baird has broken a clear and unequivocal commitment to introduce spending and donation caps for council elections,” Mr Foley said.

[quote]“Caps on donations are not much use without limits on election spending. Predatory interests will be able to spend as much as they like to capture control of a local council.”[/quote]

Shadow Local Government Minister Peter Primrose said while it was still too early to give a definitive assessment of the latest laws, people needed to remember that decisions at amalgamated councils – including ones that could flow from the new laws –were being made by government appointed administrators rather than councillors answerable to electors until September 2017.

Mr Primrose also questioned whether the Baird Government was really committed to ensuring integrity in council decisions given Budget cuts meted out to the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) that had persistently uncovered graft and dodgy decisions.

“The Premier who is behind this bill is also responsible for slashing staff at ICAC – one of the most important institutions that that maintains integrity in local government,” Mr Primrose told Parliament on Wednesday.

Referencing State Budget papers, Mr Primrose said ICAC’s “corruption prevention presentations will drop from 160 to 100” and that the average time to deal with complaints would rise from 30 days to 42 days.

“So much for promoting integrity measures,” Mr Primrose said.


Massive Audit Office Workload

While the new legislation is yet to pass, a clear intention of the new laws is to remove the ability of councillors to appoint their own auditors and hand oversight power to the directly Auditor General.

[quote]The changes mean that while the government will get a centralised and consistent view of local government finances, the Audit Office of NSW will need to compile literally hundreds of new council reports a year to perform its new duty.[/quote]

A spokesperson for Mr Toole said changes brought NSW “into line with most other Australian jurisdictions and New Zealand and will provide greater consistency and certainty across the sector.”

“It will also ensure that reliable financial information is available that can be used to assess councils’ performance and for benchmarking.

Mr Toole’s Office also confirmed that the Auditor-General will have powers to “conduct sector-wide performance audits to identify trends and opportunities for improvement across the sector” in line with similar powers in relation to state agencies.

The total cost of the audits – which are typically charged back to agencies – is still yet to be determined.

A state public service source suggested that putting councils under the watch of the Auditor General was “unquestionably” the right move, but one that may not work in Macquarie Street’s favour if ministers relied on rubbery numbers.

Premier Baird in February 2016 announced that Margaret Crawford,  who has been Deputy Secretary at the state’s Department of Family and Community Services, would become the new Auditor General of NSW.

Key changes as flagged by the Minister for Local Government

  • Appoint the Auditor-General as the auditor of all councils;
  • clarify roles and responsibilities of councillors, mayors, administrators and general managers;
  • introduce new guiding principles for local government;
  • improve governance of councils and professional development for councillors;
  • consolidate the ethical conduct obligations of councillors;
  • establish the framework for strategic business planning and reporting; and
  • streamline council administrative processes.

Comment below to have your say on this story.

If you have a news story or tip-off, get in touch at  

Sign up to the Government News newsletter

12 thoughts on “Best of 2016: Baird seizes financial control of NSW councils

  1. Why is it that their rhetorical doesnt add up? Great Lakes Council was Fit for Futue,met all IPART’s requiremnt finacially yet Baird & Toole sacked them.
    Their political greedy, self serving motives are all just that.
    If Mike Baird & Toole were put to the same tests & accountabilites as Local Gov they would be sacked & by right should be put in jail for their blatant pillaging of #NSW’s assests & life support systems.

    1. Gundagai is the most undemocratic area in NSW manipulated by poorly educated weathershed boy thugs. Good on the NSW Government for taking over the direct financial control of Councils.

      1. Treanor Jones, you are the most insulting offensive person ever!! What is a “weathershed boy thug”? You are totally without logic or reason! No one wants to read your rubbishy comments. This horrible forced merger by Baird is the worst thing that could happen to Gundagai. There is nothing in this merger which is advantageous to the town. Gundagai had a perfectly good council with very competent community minded councillors until Baird decided to sack them, with no good reason!!!

  2. About time something was done.

    So many local People have written to the Minister about Clarence Valley Council.
    We have all the problems referred to and then some.

    It cannot happen to soon.
    “A Government appointed financial controller to councils that have a consistent record of poor financial performance and get those councils back on track” is welcome in the Clarence.

    The Day our Unfit for the Present Clarence Valley Council can ‘get back on track’ and stop building the monuments it has Not discussed with the local Community but focus on reducing its huge debts and repairing its trust deficit and credibility with the local Community:

    That is the day the People of the Clarence can breathe a huge sigh of relief.

  3. Each day I check the mainstream press in the vain hope that the Land and Environment court has rejected the ridiculous claim by Hunters Hill council challenging the amalgamation of this backwater administration.

    A once fine institution has descended into a fiefdom of the most ridiculous measure – if it wasn’t so dangerous and affected so many residents directly it would be comical.

    Cranking up zoning on council land and then hocking it off to an off shore property developer without public tender, only to find out three years later it was sold for a paltry sum.

    Please Mike – save us from the Mayor and GM, I beg you!!!

  4. Wollondilly, Campbelltown & Camden councils are a perfect example of Liberal Domination, none of them fit for the future, yet escape, wonder why. Perfect example Wollondilly have 840 km of Roads to maintain, with 1 Road crew & millions of dollars backlog of infrastructure.

  5. When Wollondilly Residents & Ratepayers Association began questioning Council on expenditure and accountability in 2011, Council, on a motion from the former Mayor Benn Banasik, imposed punitive sanctions against the Association for asking too many questions. Without procedural fairness, Council passed a resolution (R41/2014) declaring the Association “unreasonable complainants” in addition to limiting WRRA to one question per month, blocked WRRA members from email contact with Council and all 9 councillors on instructions of the previous general manager Les McMahon and defamed the Association in a submission to the Office of Local Government that denied WRRA the basic right of procedural fairness, all because we asked questions regarding council’s expenditure and performance. WRRA sought declaration from the Supreme Court which they defended at huge expense to the public purse and then rescinded the restrictions before the matter was heard in the Supreme Court.

    I heartily endorse the Baird Government’s initiative to seize financial control of Wollondilly Shire Council and totally support key changes being flagged by the Local Government Minister Paul Toole, although when WRRA made formal complaints to him regarding Council imposing punitive sanctions on our organisation for asking questions, he didn’t want to know.

    The key changes flagged by the Minister for Local Government are:
    • Appoint the Auditor-General as the auditor of all councils;
    • clarify roles and responsibilities of councillors, mayors, administrators and general managers;
    • introduce new guiding principles for local government;
    • improve governance of councils and professional development for councillors;
    • consolidate the ethical conduct obligations of councillors;
    • establish the framework for strategic business planning and reporting; and
    • streamline council administrative processes.

    Based on my 30 year experience with Wollondilly Shire Council as a ratepayer and former councillor, it can’t happen quick enough.
    Lynette Styles

  6. In 4 years (after Mike Bairds departure) and the cap on rates is lifted…. every ratepayer will be worse off with increased rates and reduced services.
    We will look back then at what a sham process this amalgamation of Councils was…and realise that the real agenda all along was development…. and nothing to do with services for the people.
    Don’t be fooled, we are living in a dictatorship!!

  7. The Council Amalgamations and Financial Controls are not about making Councils more accountable to their residents, its about a State Government Coup and a dictatorship, strengthening the hand of Developers and squashing any resistance by Communities to urban density.

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be published. All fields are required